How do mortgage brokers get paid?
The short answer
Almost every broker is paid by the lender when your mortgage completes. Some are paid by you as well, through a fee that might be fixed or a percentage of the loan.
"Fee-free" means you pay nothing directly. It does not mean the broker works for nothing. The lender pays instead.
The exact amount the lender pays is written down. It has to appear on your mortgage illustration, so you never need to guess.
The fee question that matters most is when it is payable. A fee charged on application can be lost if the purchase falls through.
The two ways a broker is paid
A mortgage broker, which the rules call a mortgage intermediary, earns money in one or both of two ways.
From the lender. When a mortgage the broker arranged completes, the lender pays the broker. This is usually called a procuration fee, or "proc fee", and it is the main income for most brokers. It is paid by the lender out of its own pocket. It is not added to your loan and you do not see it on your statement.
From you. Many brokers also charge the customer directly. This can be a flat fee, a percentage of the amount borrowed, or occasionally an hourly rate. Some charge nothing at all and rely entirely on the lender's payment, which is what "fee-free" means.
Neither model is better in itself. A broker who charges you a fee is not necessarily giving better advice, and a fee-free broker is not necessarily cutting corners. What matters is that you know what you are paying, when, and what you get for it.
Where a broker's money comes from
Almost every broker
Some brokers, as well
Does going through a broker change your rate?
Usually not. On most products the lender offers the same rate whether you apply through a broker or go direct, which is why a fee-free broker generally costs you nothing extra. The lender treats the broker's payment as a cost of finding customers, in the same way it pays for branches and advertising.
There are two exceptions worth knowing about. Some lenders keep certain deals for customers who come to them directly, and those never appear on a broker's screen. Others release products only through brokers. Neither is common enough to change the general picture, but it is one reason to glance at your own bank's current deals before deciding.
Where to find the exact figure
You do not have to ask awkwardly, or take anyone's word for it. The FCA's mortgage rules require two separate disclosures.
At the start, before giving advice, the broker must tell you what fees it will charge you and how it is paid. That normally arrives as a short document or a page on the firm's website, and it should state the fee and the point at which you become liable for it.
Before you apply, you receive a European Standardised Information Sheet, or ESIS, sometimes just called the mortgage illustration. If the lender is paying the broker commission, the ESIS must state the amount, in pounds. Look for the section about the intermediary. If the exact figure is not known yet, the document has to show representative examples instead.
Fees charged to you: what to look at
The headline amount matters less than three other things.
When it is payable. Brokers charge at different points: when you instruct them, when the application goes in, when the mortgage offer is issued, or on completion. A fee payable on completion is only paid if you actually get the mortgage. A fee payable earlier can be lost if the seller pulls out, the survey goes badly or the chain collapses. On a purchase, that risk is real, so a fee taken on completion is worth a great deal.
Whether it is refundable. If any of the fee is due before completion, ask in writing what happens if the purchase falls through. Some brokers refund in full, some refund part, and some keep it.
How it compares to the size of the job. A percentage fee grows with the loan, even though a larger mortgage is rarely much more work. On a big loan, a fixed fee can be considerably cheaper.
Put a number on it Compare two mortgage dealsAdd the broker fee to the product fee and see whether a slightly cheaper rate is still cheaper once every fee is counted. Nothing you enter is stored or transmitted.
Whole of market, panel or single lender
Brokers also differ in how many lenders they look at, and they have to tell you which kind they are before advising you.
- Whole of market: the broker considers products from across the market, apart from deals lenders keep for direct customers.
- Limited number of lenders: the broker works from a panel. The panel can be large or small, and it is reasonable to ask how many lenders are on it and whether your own bank is one of them.
- Single lender: the adviser can only recommend one lender's mortgages. This is what you get from a bank's own mortgage adviser, and sometimes from an adviser attached to an estate agent or housebuilder.
A firm may only call itself independent if its range across the market is unlimited. A broker working from a panel may be perfectly good, but it should not be describing itself that way.
Does commission influence the advice?
It is a fair question, and the honest answer is that the rules are designed to stop it, but the incentive does exist.
Lenders do not all pay the same amount, so in principle a broker earns more from some recommendations than others. Against that, an advised mortgage has to be suitable for you, and the FCA's Consumer Duty requires firms to act to deliver good outcomes for their customers and to offer fair value. A broker who steered customers towards the best-paying lender rather than the right one would be breaking those rules.
The practical safeguard is simple. Ask why the broker recommended this lender over the alternatives. A good broker can answer immediately, in terms of your circumstances: the lender accepts your type of income, the fees suit the size of your loan, the rate is fixed for the period you need. An answer that never gets past "it is a good deal" is worth probing.
Renewing your mortgage through a broker
When a fixed rate ends, you can usually switch to a new deal with your existing lender, called a product transfer, either through a broker or directly with the lender. Many lenders pay brokers for arranging product transfers too.
If your circumstances have not changed and you are happy to stay with your lender, going direct is often perfectly adequate. A broker earns their keep when they check whether moving lender would be cheaper, or when something has changed, such as your income, the amount you want to borrow, or the property's value. Some brokers charge a separate fee for product transfers, so check before agreeing.
Related Guide: what to do when a fixed rate is endingProduct transfer or remortgage, when to start, and what happens if you do nothing.
The estate agent's mortgage adviser
Many estate agents have an in-house or partner adviser, and buyers are often asked to "have a quick chat" with them after an offer. You are under no obligation to use them.
The Estate Agents (Undesirable Practices) (No. 2) Order 1991 prevents an agent from treating a buyer less favourably for declining its services, and requires it to pass every offer to the seller unless the seller has told it otherwise. National Trading Standards guidance adds that pressuring a buyer into using an agent's services, or holding back an offer because they refused, can breach consumer protection law as well.
The agent's adviser may still be a good choice. Just make it a choice, and ask the same questions you would ask anyone else, including whether they cover the whole market or a single lender.
Next step Guide: from offer accepted to completionWhat happens after the offer, where the delays come from, and when each cost falls due.
When a broker is most worth having
For a straightforward borrower with a regular salary, a clean credit file and a decent deposit, going direct to a lender is a reasonable option, and plenty of people do it successfully.
A broker adds most value when your case is not straightforward: self-employed or contractor income, bonuses or commission making up a large part of your pay, a past credit problem, a small deposit, an unusual property, or a purchase on a tight timescale. Lenders differ widely on all of these, and knowing which ones will say yes is most of what a good broker sells. They also chase the lender and the solicitors, which on a purchase can matter as much as the rate.
Background Guide: how lenders decide what you can borrowIncome multiples, affordability testing and why two lenders can give very different answers for the same person.
Before you sign anything
These checks take a few minutes and cover almost everything that goes wrong.
- Check the FCA Register. Search the firm at register.fca.org.uk and confirm it is authorised for mortgage advice. If the adviser works for an appointed representative, the register shows the principal firm that is responsible for them.
- Get the fee in writing, including the amount, when it is payable and whether any of it is refundable if the purchase falls through.
- Ask about scope. Whole of market, a panel, or one lender, and how many lenders on any panel.
- Read the commission figure on the ESIS when it arrives.
- Ask why this lender and expect an answer in terms of your circumstances.
If something goes wrong
Complain to the firm first. If it does not resolve the complaint within eight weeks, or you are unhappy with its final response, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which is free to use.
If the firm has gone out of business and you lost money because of poor mortgage advice, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme may be able to help. The FSCS states that for firms that failed after 1 April 2019 it can pay up to £85,000 per eligible person, per firm, where the mortgage was on your main home.