How to compare energy tariffs properly
The short answer
Compare the cost of a full year, not the rates. For each tariff: unit rate times your annual usage, plus standing charge times 365, plus any fee for leaving your current deal.
Use your real usage in kWh, from your annual statement or last twelve months of bills. The cheapest tariff for a low user is often not the cheapest for a high one.
Treat a comparison site's saving as an estimate. It depends on the usage you typed in, and the site may not be showing every tariff.
Check the exit fee and the end date. Suppliers cannot charge one in the last 49 days of a fixed term.
Step 1: find your real usage
Everything else depends on this number, and it is the one most people guess. Your supplier sends an annual statement showing how many kilowatt hours (kWh) of electricity and gas you used over the past year. Your bills and app show it too. Add up twelve months if you can, because usage swings a lot between summer and winter.
Avoid working back from your monthly direct debit. The direct debit is the supplier's estimate of what you will spend, smoothed across the year and sometimes building up a credit balance, so it is not a reliable guide to what you use.
If you have just moved in and have no history, Ofgem's typical consumption values are a reasonable starting point: about 2,500 kWh of electricity and 9,500 kWh of gas a year for a medium household. Replace them with your own figures as soon as you have a few months of readings.
Step 2: get both parts of each price
Almost every tariff in Great Britain has two parts, for each fuel.
The unit rate is the price per kWh you use. The standing charge is a fixed amount per day that you pay whether you use anything or not. Your current rates are on your bill. For a new deal, they are in the tariff information or the quote's small print; any supplier or comparison site must be able to give them to you.
If you have Economy 7 or another two-rate meter, you need the day rate, the night rate and how your usage splits between them. Get the payment method right too: quotes for direct debit, prepayment and paying on receipt of a bill are not comparable with each other.
Step 3: cost a full year for each tariff
Here is an example for electricity only. The three tariffs are invented for illustration and are not real offers.
Tariff A, your current deal: 27p per kWh and 55p a day. Tariff B, a fixed deal: 24.5p per kWh and 60p a day. Tariff C, a low standing charge deal: 32p per kWh and 20p a day.
| Annual usage | What each tariff costs |
|---|---|
| 1,800 kWh | A £686.75, B £660.00, C £649.00. C is cheapest. |
| 2,500 kWh | A £875.75, B £831.50, C £873.00. B is cheapest. |
| 3,500 kWh | A £1,145.75, B £1,076.50, C £1,193.00. B is cheapest, and C is now the dearest. |
The same three tariffs give a different winner depending on usage. That is why the usage figure in step 1 matters more than anything a comparison site's ranking tells you.
The cost of a full year, for each tariff
Step 4: find the break-even point
Whenever one tariff has a lower standing charge and a higher unit rate than another, there is an annual usage at which they cost exactly the same. Below it, the lower standing charge wins. Above it, the lower unit rate wins.
For tariffs A and C above, that is 365 × (55 − 20) ÷ (32 − 27), which is 2,555 kWh a year. If your usage sits close to the break-even point, the two tariffs are effectively the same and you can choose on other grounds, such as the supplier's service. If you are well away from it, the answer is clear. The standing charges guide works through this in more detail.
Run your own numbers Energy comparison calculatorEnter your current tariff and any quote, with your own usage, Economy 7 and gas, and see which is cheaper over a year, where the break-even sits, and what an exit fee does to the first year. Nothing you enter is stored or transmitted.
Step 5: add the cost of leaving
If you are on a fixed tariff, check whether it has an exit fee and when it ends. Exit fees are usually charged per fuel, so a dual fuel customer can pay two. Add the fee to the first year's cost of the new tariff before comparing.
Suppliers cannot charge an exit fee if you switch in the last 49 days of a fixed term. If your deal ends within the next couple of months, waiting can save the fee entirely. Standard variable tariffs, the ones limited by the price cap, have no exit fees.
Fixed or variable?
The Ofgem price cap limits the unit rates and standing charges on standard variable tariffs in England, Scotland and Wales, and it changes every three months. It is not a cap on your total bill: use more, and you pay more.
A fixed tariff holds its rates for a set period, usually a year or more. Comparing a fix with a variable tariff at today's prices is only a snapshot, because the variable rate will move at the next quarterly review and nobody knows which way. A more useful question is how far variable rates would have to rise, or fall, before the fix stopped being the better choice. The calculator works that out for you.
What comparison sites do, and do not, show you
Comparison sites are useful for seeing which tariffs are available where you live. It helps to know how they work.
They are usually paid by suppliers when you switch through them. That is allowed and is how the service stays free, but it means a site may by default show only the tariffs it can switch you to. Look for an option to see all tariffs.
Ofgem accredits comparison services under its Confidence Code, which sets standards for accuracy and impartiality. Using an accredited site is sensible.
The headline saving is an estimate. It compares the new tariff with what the site thinks you pay now, using the usage you entered. If you typed in your monthly spend rather than your kWh, the site has estimated your usage, and the saving may be off by a long way. Check the rates the site shows against your own bill.
Rankings can hide conditions. Look for discounts that only apply with direct debit or paperless billing, one-off credits that flatter the first year, and bundled extras such as boiler cover that make a tariff look more or less expensive than it is on rates alone.
Things worth checking before you switch
- Supplier service. A few pounds a year matters less than how a supplier handles a billing mistake. Citizens Advice publishes ratings of energy suppliers' customer service.
- Smart meter and time-of-use tariffs. Tariffs where the price changes by time of day can be cheap if you can move usage, such as charging an electric car overnight, and expensive if you cannot. A single unit rate comparison does not capture them.
- Credit balance. If your account is in credit when you leave, your old supplier should refund it once the final bill is settled.
- Debt on your account. Owing money can affect whether you can switch, particularly on a prepayment meter. Ask your supplier or Citizens Advice before you start.
- Renting. If you pay the energy bills directly, you can normally choose your own supplier, but check your tenancy agreement.
How switching works
Once you have chosen, you only need to contact the new supplier, either directly or through a comparison site. The new supplier arranges the switch and tells your old one. Your supply is not interrupted, no one needs to visit, and the pipes and wires stay the same. Take a meter reading on the switch date so your final and opening bills are accurate.
You normally have 14 days to change your mind after agreeing a new contract.
Northern Ireland
Northern Ireland is outside the Ofgem price cap and has its own regulator, the Utility Regulator. The method on this page still works, because it only needs your usage and each tariff's rates, but the switching rules and the available suppliers are different. The Consumer Council for Northern Ireland runs its own price comparison.
If energy bills are becoming hard to manage, speak to your supplier early: suppliers must offer payment arrangements that take account of what you can afford. Citizens Advice gives free help with energy bills and can tell you whether you qualify for the Warm Home Discount or other support.